Vital Football

Latest Birmingham City News

Squad Review

Squad Review

With the season fast approaching and the pre-season fixtures beginning it is important for manager Lee Clark to find his best eleven for the season ahead. With nine new additions to the squad and with rumours continuing to rumble about one or two more arrivals yet things are looking good for the blues this season. The squad in full as it stands is listed here.

I am going to be picking my starting eleven using a 442 diamond shape.
In terms of goalkeepers it is a very simple choice with Randolph retaining his starting role in between the sticks as he is a good keeper and only conceded so many last season due to the quantity of chances going through at him. Despite this some chances could have and should have been prevented see the final game of the season against Bolton.

By embedding this video we do not claim to own it or the rights to it.

The defence was a weak area for the blues last season and manager Lee Clark will surely be keen to prevent the same weakness this season. With Neal Eardley returning from injury he can be seen as a new signing and it will be interesting to see him and Paul Caddis fighting it out for the Right full back role. Both players boast the speed needed to overlap the right mid and the ability to produce a quality cross as well as being defensively solid so this will be a good duel to see throughout the season.

The pairing of centre backs will be crucial if fans hopes of a high finish are going to be met and Lee Clark has got to be able to get this correct early on and let the pair gel together. I feel will Packwood has to be selected on the basis he has all the qualities of a future top centre back so I feel he needs to play and gain experience.

The problem with this means it gives Clark an issue on who is the second centre back is. Paul Robinson club captain, leader and veteran has been a key player for the blues last season and looks set to carry on with this however that was until the arrival of David Edgar. Edgar is younger then the skipper and has bags of experience in the championship winning promotion with Burnley and making 21 appearances for his former club.

With Robinson being captain it looks set for him to stay lodged at centre back however when it comes for a changing of the guard or multiple matches a week don't be surprised to see the new signing ready to make the position his own.

The left full back role should be a safe bet to remain with Mitch Hancox the Birmingham born left footer has provided plenty of passionate performances leading to him having his own song from the fans. With plenty of pace Hancox is difficult to defend against as well as attack and with the passion comes committed tackles which normally disposes opposition attackers. With this in mind it makes the left full back pick a no brainier.

The holding midfielder needs to be a warrior who is willing to tackle for 90 minutes breaking up play. Also they have to have the engine to keep going and play simple passes to the more creative members of the team. Despite this they can't be a constant anchor defensively they have to be pushed forwards when necessary to help create more pressure.

The players who will be competing for this role is: Callum Reilly, Olly Lee, Jonathan Spector, Tom Adeyemi, and Stephen Gleeson. Last season Clark tended to operate with two holding midfielders in Reilly and Adeyemi. With the dual role not being considered for my formation I will have to sacrifice one to the bench. With Spector's injury prone nature he isn't considered for my match day squad.

Olly Lee in my opinion is not up to the standard for a championship club who want to push back up the league lacking the technical ability of his team mates. This means it will be fought for between the duo of last year and new recruit Stephen Gleeson. With this in mind my selection is going to be difficult to choose between as all three possess the potential to suit the role.

The winger will need to have certain abilities to be a successful replacement for the now departed Chris Burke. The qualities needed are: pace, the ability to deliver an accurate cross as well as the legs to track back to help out the full back and also a good ball control to attack the defence when dribbling with the ball.

The player who is picked will need to fill not only the boots of Burke but also make the role his own as the man to stand where club heroes such as Larsson and Redmond have previously stood. The candidates for this role are: Koby Arthur, Demarai Gray, Mark Duffy and David Cotterill. All candidates have these abilities in bags and will be fiercely competing for this role.

The creative presence that will be sat behind the strike force will need to be able to pick a pass as well as be able to create space for a shot and win free kicks for his team. The players I am considering for this role are: Lee Novak, Andrew Shinnie, Reece Brown, and Stephen Gleeson. Novak`s work rate and ability to strike from distance is proven at championship level makes him a strong pick for this role. Reece Brown only made a few appearances for the team last season however one was against Swansea in which he more then looked capable next to Premier League players.

Andrew Shinnie showed form in the pre-season but never seemed to demonstrate this in competitive environment in any of the domestic competitions last season. Shinnie does have potential should he be given time however with a team that needs to have a good start can Clark afford to give him this lenient policy. Gleeson is an unknown player at this level of football so any performances during the pre-season period will have to be taken with a pinch of salt which is why he will be not included in my eleven.

The striker`s role will be simple convert chances that are presented and made from those around them however it isn't as simple as that. They will also need to make chances for each other as well as learn each other`s game to form a partnership and follow the play of those around them. The strikers who are available for this are: Lee Novak, Clayton Donaldson, Matt Green and Wes Thomas. My first pick is Clayton Donaldson as he is the oldest option of the 4 and has experience at different levels and leagues.

This is needed as it means he can adapt to different styles of defending and also a variety of ways of playing as part of a team. The final player of this team is being competed between for Lee Novak and Matt Green as both have youth on their side yet to hit their peaks. I will elect for Novak as he is versatile and finished as Birmingham's top goal scorer with 11 league goals.

GK - Randolph
RB - Caddis/Eardley
CB - Robinson
CB - Packwood
LB - Hancox
CDM - Adeyemi
RM - Mark Duffy
LM - Koby Arthur
CAM - Reece Brown
ST - Clayton Donaldson
ST - Lee Novak

Click Here to sign up for our site, make yourself and your ideas heard in the comments below!

To find me on Twitter just Click Here

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Carl Eustace
Date:Tuesday July 8 2014
Time: 10:30AM


Think hes after another left winger. I think Shinnie will play CAM and Cotterill left wing if no one comes in. Also think that Arthur might not be in Clarks plans just yet as he isnt in Ireland with the team. Not sure why you haven't considered Hall or Gunning as starters, Think Hall will definitely be a start at the beginning of the season as Tottenham will be expecting him to play a lot being as there is no re-call option on him.
08/07/2014 11:35:00
Shinnie is one big joke, waste of wages
08/07/2014 15:16:00
I don't think he's that bad
08/07/2014 17:38:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Best of Vital Network

Recent Birmingham City Articles

New EFL Radio Deal Starts 2017/18

The Football League confirmed yesterday that a new three year deal with Talksport and the BBC had been signed to increase radio broadcast coverage from next season.

Harry Redknapp setting the bench mark

Harry Redknapp is building the depths of the squad

Blues should look to capitalise on Leeds United turmoil

Tom Heslop discusses one player he thinks Birmingham City should sign from fellow Championship side Leeds United

Offering Robbo a new deal a good move by Redknapp

Tom Heslop has his say on the news that Paul Robinson has been offered a new one year contract by the club

Archived Vital Birmingham Articles

Vital Birmingham articles from

Site Journalists

Tom Heslop
Editor email
Christopher Handy
no email
Saskia Bowes
no email
Rob Wildey
no email
Luke Turner
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Should Blues appoint Harry Redknapp permanently?
Suggested By: Vital Blues staff
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
C Newcastle 46 29 7 10 94 45
P Brighton 46 28 9 9 93 34
3 Reading 46 26 7 13 85 4
4 Sheff Wed 46 24 9 13 81 15
5 Huddersfield 46 25 6 15 81 -2
6 Fulham 46 22 14 10 80 28
7 Leeds Utd 46 22 9 15 75 14
8 Norwich 46 20 10 16 70 16
9 Derby County 46 18 13 15 67 4
10 Brentford 46 18 10 18 64 10
11 Preston 46 16 14 16 62 1
12 Cardiff 46 17 11 18 62 -1
13 Aston Villa 46 16 14 16 62 -1
14 Barnsley 46 15 13 18 58 -3
15 Wolves 46 16 10 20 58 -4
16 Ipswich 46 13 16 17 55 -10
17 Bristol City 46 15 9 22 54 -6
18 Q.P.R. 46 15 8 23 53 -14
19 Birmingham 46 13 14 19 53 -19
20 Burton 46 13 13 20 52 -14
21 Forest 46 14 9 23 51 -10
R Blackburn 46 12 15 19 51 -12
R Wigan 46 10 12 24 42 -17
R Rotherham 46 5 8 33 23 -58
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Birmingham City Results (view all)

Birmingham City Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

3.David Village31
6.Rob Wildey110
7.Sausage n egg8
The Vital Football Members League